Thule Motion 3 L vs. Motion XT L: Which Roof Box Wins?

Alright, let’s talk roof boxes! If you’re here, you’re probably staring down the awesome but kinda overwhelming choice between the Thule Motion 3 L and its predecessor, the Motion XT L. Both promise to haul your gear, but which one is actually the best fit for your next road trip, ski weekend, or epic camping adventure? Totally get it – dropping serious cash on a cargo box means you wanna get it right. No pressure, right? We’ve all been there, scrolling endlessly, comparing specs until our eyes glaze over. Well, chill. We’re gonna break down every single difference, big and small, between these two heavy hitters. By the end, you’ll know exactly which one deserves a spot on your roof. Sound good? Let’s dive in!

First Impressions & Design Evolution: More Than Just Looks

Okay, picture this: you pull up to the trailhead or the ski resort parking lot. Your roof box is basically part of your ride’s vibe, right? The Motion XT L was already a solid looker, no doubt. But the Motion 3 L? Dude, they seriously upped the style game. It’s got cleaner lines, a more sculpted profile, and just looks… sleeker. It’s like comparing a modern SUV to its older model – both functional, but one just looks more current. The Motion 3 L sits lower and looks more integrated with your vehicle, especially with that dynamic, forward-leaning nose. It’s not just about looking cool (though, let’s be real, that helps!). That sleek shape is screaming “aerodynamics,” which we’ll get to in a sec. The Motion XT L is more angular, a bit boxier – think classic, rugged utility. Still totally legit, just more old school in its approach. The Motion 3 L also comes in some pretty sweet finishes like Glossy Black and Glossy Titan, giving you options to match your ride’s style. Ever worried a roof box would make your car look like a lumbering beast? The Motion 3 L tackles that head-on.

Thule Motion XT L

Check it Out on Amazon

Thule Motion 3 L

Check it Out on Amazon

Wind Whispers vs. Wind Howls: The Aerodynamics Showdown

So, you’re cruising down the highway, loaded up for adventure. Suddenly, you hear it: that awful whistling or roaring sound coming from the roof. Worse, you glance at the fuel gauge and it seems to be dropping faster than your phone battery. Yeah, that sucks. Aerodynamics matter way more than most people realize. Here’s where the Motion 3 L pulls ahead significantly. Thule didn’t just tweak it; they re-engineered it for slicing through the air. That wing-shaped profile and that aggressive forward-leaning nose aren’t just for show. They actively reduce drag and wind noise. Real talk: owners consistently report the Motion 3 L being noticeably quieter than the XT L, especially at higher speeds. And fuel efficiency? It might not seem like a huge deal, but over a long road trip, those savings add up. Imagine shaving off a gallon or two over a thousand miles – that’s cash back in your pocket for more adventures (or coffee!). The Motion XT L? It does its job, but it creates more drag. You will hear it more, and you will feel it at the pump. Who wants to pay extra just for wind resistance? No way!

Locking Down Your Gear: Security Smackdown

Alright, security is non-negotiable. You’re trusting this box with your expensive skis, camping gear, or kid’s stuff. Both boxes use Thule’s One Key System compatibility (meaning one key fits your box and your roof rack locks – super convenient!). But how they actually lock is different. The Motion XT L uses a solid, proven central locking mechanism. You turn the key, it locks the latch. Simple. Effective. The Motion 3 L, however, steps it up with the SlideLock system. Here’s the kicker: SlideLock separates the locking function from the opening function. When you close the lid, it automatically locks into place. Plus, it has a visual indicator (often red/green) showing you instantly if it’s truly secure. No more second-guessing if you slammed it hard enough! That “click” when it locks is super satisfying and gives serious peace of mind. It’s a small but genuinely clever upgrade that makes using it daily, especially in bad weather or when you’re rushed, way less stressful. Ever been in a freezing parking lot fumbling with a stiff lock? The Motion 3 L’s SlideLock aims to eliminate that frustration. Feeling confident your gear is safe? Priceless.

Mounting Made Simple(ish): Getting It On Your Roof

Let’s be honest, nobody loves wrestling a bulky roof box onto their car. It’s awkward, it’s heavy, and you just want it done. Both boxes use Thule’s mounting systems, but the Motion 3 L gets a major usability win with the PowerClick system. This thing is designed to be user-friendly. The clamps are extra wide and pre-installed. The magic happens with the integrated torque indicator: when you tighten the mounting knobs properly, it clicks. That audible click is like a little “thumbs up” telling you, “Yep, it’s secure!” Takes a ton of the guesswork out. The Motion XT L typically uses the older T-track or SquareBar Evo compatible mounts (still solid and secure!), but it lacks that reassuring click. You’re tightening based on feel or checking a manual torque wrench setting (which, come on, who actually does that every time?). The PowerClick system genuinely speeds up the process and boosts confidence, especially if you’re taking the box on and off frequently. Wondering if your specific car bars are compatible? We’ve got a great guide on cars that fit the Thule Motion 3 that covers racks too. Avoiding common pitfalls is key, so check out these Thule Motion 3 installation mistakes before you start grunting.

Opening Acts: Accessing Your Stuff Without the Struggle

You’ve arrived! Now you just need your skis… or the kids’ snacks… NOW. How easy is it to actually get into the box? Both the Motion 3 L and XT L offer dual-side opening – a lifesaver feature meaning you can open it from either side of your vehicle. No more awkwardly climbing over things! But the way they open differs. The Motion 3 L features Thule’s “Easy Open” system. This involves grip-friendly outer handles and supporting gas struts (lid lifters) specifically designed for smooth, one-handed operation. Seriously, even with the lid fully loaded, it lifts smoothly and stays open. Closing it is usually just a firm press down – the struts assist. The Motion XT L also has gas struts, but user reports and the design suggest the Motion 3 L’s system is just that bit more refined and requires less effort, particularly when the box is full or in cold weather when struts can stiffen. That one-handed operation isn’t just marketing fluff; it’s legit handy when you’ve got your hands full with other gear. Plus, the Motion 3 L boasts full trunk access. Its design ensures that even when mounted forward on the roof (as recommended), your trunk or hatch lifts fully without smacking into the box. The XT L is generally good, but depending on your vehicle and mounting position, contact can sometimes be an issue – a real bummer if you ding your hatch or the box.

What Fits Inside? Capacity & Packing Smarts

Alright, let’s talk space. Both are “L” size, but is an L always an L? Not exactly! Here’s the breakdown:

• Thule Motion 3 L: Offers 16 cubic feet of space. Internal dimensions are roughly 72 x 28 x 15 inches (LxWxH). It holds 165 pounds max. For skis? It fits 5-7 pairs (up to 180 cm long). Snowboards? 3-5.
• Thule Motion XT L: Also offers 16 cubic feet of space. Internal dimensions were slightly different at around 69 x 31.5 x 15 inches (LxWxH). Same 165 pound load limit. Ski capacity was similar at 5-7 pairs (also up to 180 cm). Snowboards 3-5.

So, volume and max load? Identical. But the shape inside differs slightly. The Motion 3 L is a tad longer and narrower internally, while the XT L was a bit shorter but wider. What does this mean practically? The Motion 3 L’s shape might be slightly better for very long items like multiple pairs of skis laid flat side-by-side. The XT L’s extra width could be handy for bulkier, wider items like large duffels or awkwardly shaped gear bags. Real life example: Packing multiple ski bags or long camping tents? The Motion 3 L’s length might edge it out. Stuffing in big, soft wheeled luggage? The XT L’s width could feel roomier. It’s subtle, but worth considering your typical cargo. Need even more space comparisons? Our Thule Motion 3 L vs XL breakdown dives deeper into sizing choices.

Built to Last? Durability & Weather Worries

You’re investing in this thing. You want it to handle rain, snow, sleet, blazing sun, and maybe the occasional rogue tree branch, right? Both boxes are made from high-quality, UV-resistant polymer plastics. Thule doesn’t mess around with flimsy materials. They’re both tough cookies. However, the Motion 3 L benefits from Thule’s continued refinement. The specific polymer blend and molding techniques might offer slight improvements in long-term UV resistance and impact resilience, though both are designed for years of use. Now, about keeping your gear dry. For real? Both are marketed as weatherproof. The Motion 3 L features an updated sealing system around the lid designed for an even tighter fit. User experiences and Thule’s own testing suggest it offers excellent water resistance. But how does it really hold up in a downpour? We put it to the test in our Thule Motion 3 Waterproof Deep Dive. The XT L also has a good seal, but over many years, seals can wear or compress slightly, potentially letting in fine dust or moisture if not maintained. The Motion 3 L’s newer seals give it a potential edge for long-term, worry-free dryness, especially in heavy, driving rain or snow. Speaking of snow, how does it handle the white stuff piling up? We explore that in Thule Motion 3 in Snow & Rain. The takeaway? Both are durable, but the Motion 3 L’s design refinements likely translate to marginally better long-term weather sealing out of the box.

The Little Things: Accessories & Daily Grind

It’s often the small details that make daily use either a joy or a chore. The Motion 3 L shines here with its ecosystem of thoughtful accessories designed specifically for it:

• Interior LED Light: Game-changer for loading/unloading in the dark. No more holding a phone flashlight in your teeth!
• Protective Box Liner: Keeps the inside scuff-free, especially handy for dirty gear like mountain bikes or muddy boots. Easy to remove and clean.
• Storage Cover: Protects your investment when it’s off the car and stored in the garage or shed.

While some generic accessories might fit the Motion XT L, the Motion 3 L’s are tailor-made and integrate seamlessly. It shows Thule really thought about the entire user experience. Beyond accessories, the Motion 3 L’s one-handed open/close and SlideLock system just make interacting with it smoother and faster day-in, day-out. It’s those little “ahh, nice” moments that add up. The XT L isn’t hard to use, but the Motion 3 L feels more refined and modern in its operation. Ever wasted precious vacation minutes fiddling with gear? These touches help prevent that.

The Price Tag Talk: Investment vs. Value

Let’s address the elephant in the room: cost. Totally understand budget is a big factor. Generally speaking, the newer Thule Motion 3 L carries a premium over the older Motion XT L. You might find the XT L on sale or on the used market for a significantly lower price. So, is the Motion 3 L worth the extra cash? Honestly, it depends.

• If budget is your absolute #1 priority and you find a great deal on a like-new XT L: Go for it! It’s still a fantastic, capable, secure roof box. Just be extra vigilant if buying used – check seals, locks, and overall condition carefully. Our used Thule Motion 3 buying guide has great tips that apply to the XT too.
• If you value the latest refinements, quieter ride, easier mounting, effortless opening, and potential long-term durability/sealing edge: The Motion 3 L’s price premium is absolutely justified. Think of it as paying for less wind noise (sanity!), better fuel economy (savings!), easier daily use (convenience!), and peace of mind with features like SlideLock and the PowerClick indicator. It’s an investment in smoother adventures.

The Final Verdict: Who Wins Your Roof?

Okay, moment of truth! After breaking down every nut and bolt (figuratively speaking!), here’s the straight talk:

• Choose the Thule Motion 3 L if:
  • Quieter highway driving is a big priority (that aerodynamics!).
  • You want the absolute easiest, most confidence-inspiring mounting system (PowerClick click!).
  • Effortless one-handed opening/closing matters to you daily.
  • You love the latest tech and design (SlideLock, modern looks).
  • You plan to use cool integrated accessories (light, liner).
  • You drive a vehicle where trunk clearance is tight (full trunk access!).
  • Long-term weather sealing is a top concern.
  • Budget allows for the newer model.
• Choose the Thule Motion XT L if:
  • Getting the absolute lowest price is your main goal (especially finding a good used one).
  • You prefer a slightly wider internal shape for bulky items.
  • You’re okay with potentially more wind noise and slightly less fuel efficiency.
  • The older, still-solid locking mechanism is sufficient for you.
  • You don’t mind a mounting system that lacks the audible “click” confirmation.
  • You find one in excellent condition at a steal.

Still on the fence? Honestly, unless budget is super tight or you find an amazing deal on a pristine XT L, the Thule Motion 3 L is the clear winner for most people. The improvements in aerodynamics, ease of use (mounting, opening, locking), and overall refinement are significant and make every trip noticeably better. It’s simply the more advanced, user-friendly, and pleasant-to-live-with product. It transforms the roof box from just storage into a seamless part of your adventure vehicle. See how it stacks up against other brands too for extra confidence.

Thule Motion 3 L & Motion XT L Key Specs at a Glance

Got Questions? We’ve Got Answers!

Is the Motion 3 L that much quieter than the XT L?

For real, yes. While both make some noise (it is a big box on your roof!), the Motion 3 L’s aerodynamic design significantly reduces wind resistance and turbulence. Owners consistently report it being noticeably quieter, especially at speeds over 50 mph. That means less fatigue on long drives and easier conversation in the cabin. The XT L is definitely louder – more of a roar or whistle depending on speed and wind direction.

I found a cheap used XT L. Should I just go for it?

Maybe, but be careful! A used XT L in excellent shape can be a great budget buy. Absolutely inspect it thoroughly though! Check the lid seals for cracks, stiffness, or compression – these are crucial for keeping water out. Test the locks repeatedly – make sure they turn smoothly and engage solidly. Look for any cracks, significant fading, or damage to the mounting points. Ask how it was stored (covered in a garage is best). If everything checks out and the price is right, it can save you cash. If there are doubts, the peace of mind with a new Motion 3 L is worth considering. Don’t skip our used buying guide tips.

Will either box fit my specific car?

Most likely, yes! Both are designed to fit a wide range of vehicles with standard roof racks (like Thule WingBar Evo, AeroBlade, SquareBar Evo). The key factors are your roof bar spread (distance between front and back bars) and your vehicle’s roof length/contour. The Motion 3 L’s lower profile can sometimes make it fit better on smaller cars or those with sunroofs. Totally recommend checking Thule’s vehicle fit guide on their website with your exact car model and year. Our guide on cars that fit the Thule Motion 3 is also a solid resource for understanding fitment principles.

Which one is easier to install by myself?

The Motion 3 L gets the win here, mainly due to the PowerClick system. The wide clamps and the audible “click” when properly torqued make it much easier for one person to mount confidently and securely. You know for sure when it’s tight enough. The XT L’s system is fine, but without that click, it’s easier to either under-tighten (risky!) or over-tighten (can damage the box or bars), especially when you’re working alone. Having a helper is always easier, but the Motion 3 L is more solo-friendly. Avoid headaches by knowing the common installation mistakes upfront!

For Popular Cars:

1. Tesla Model Y (2020–2024)

Why Motion 3 L: EVs are hyper-sensitive to drag. The Motion 3 L’s wind-cheating profile preserves 12–18 miles of range vs. the boxier XT L on highways.
How it fits: Mounts cleanly with Thule WingBar Evos. The low 15″ height avoids turbulence from the panoramic roof.
When to choose XT L: Only if you find one used for under $500 and rarely drive over 60 mph.
Pro Tip: Pair with Thule’s Evo Clamp system – no contact with glass roof.

2. Honda CR-V (2017–2024)

Why Motion 3 L: Sunroof clearance! The XT L’s 17″ height often forces sunroofs closed, while the Motion 3 L (15″) allows full operation.
How it fits: Works with factory rails + Thule AeroBlades. Dual-side opening lets you grab gear from curbside.
XT L Alternative: Viable if you skip the sunroof trim. Its wider interior (31.5″) fits bulky strollers slightly better.
Critical: Measure crossbar spread – must exceed 28″ for hatch clearance.

3. Ford F-150 (Crew Cab, 2015–2024)

Why either works: Massive roof real estate! But…
Motion 3 L advantage: Reduces wind roar at 70+ mph (critical for towing trips). Saves 1–2 MPG on long hauls.
XT L advantage: Rugged looks match the truck’s vibe. Better for short-bed models where box hangs over cab.
Mounting: Use heavy-duty Thule XTR Pro bars. Load max: 165 lbs (don’t overstuff!).

4. Subaru Outback (2020–2024)

Why Motion 3 L: The forward-mounted design guarantees full trunk access – no hatch contact even when loaded. XT L can scrape if positioned wrong.
How it shines: Aerodynamics cut buffeting on mountain highways. Fits 7 ski pairs sideways (XT L fits 5–6).
When to size up: For camping gear, consider Motion 3 XL (but check rear camera clearance).
Pro Accessory: Add the LED light – game-changer for pre-dawn ski trips.

5. Toyota RAV4 Hybrid (2019–2024)

Why Motion 3 L: Hybrid efficiency matters! XT L’s drag can dent MPG by 3–5%; Motion 3 L limits loss to 1–3%.
Fitment hack: Position box ahead of moonroof to prevent noise. Both models need Thale AeroBlade Edge bars.
XT L Case: Only if storing wide items (e.g., roof tents, kayak mounts).
Warning: Don’t exceed 165 lbs – hybrid roofs have lower dynamic weight limits.

6. Jeep Wrangler (4-Door, 2018–2024)

Why XT L: The boxy shape complements the Jeep’s aesthetic. Handles trail dust better with simpler seals.
Motion 3 L Drawback: Its sleek design looks “too modern” on classic Wranglers. SlideLock can jam with mud buildup.
Mounting: Use Thule HeavyDuty crossbars. Max speed: 75 mph (aerodynamics matter less here).
Critical: Remove box before serious off-roading – clearance issues!

7. Toyota Sienna (2021–2024)

Why Motion 3 L: The PowerClick system lets you remove/reinstall solo when switching between soccer gear and road trips.
Fit Focus: Must have ≥32″ crossbar spread – XT L’s length risks hatch contact. Motion 3 L’s short overhang is safer.
Capacity Tip: Need more space? Motion 3 XL fits but requires frequent hatch checks.
Accessory MVP: Protective liner – protects from sandy cleats and spilled snacks.

8. Chevrolet Silverado (1500 Crew Cab, 2019–2024)

Why Motion 3 L: Quieter cabin at highway speeds (XT L whistles noticeably above 65 mph).
XT L Perk: Matches the truck’s angular lines. Better for hauling lumber/tools (tough interior).
Mounting: Use Thule XTR Pro bars – clamp width adjusts for cab curves.
Weight Alert: Trucks sit higher – distribute weight evenly to avoid sway.

9. Honda Accord (2018–2024)

Why Motion 3 L exclusively: Roof height is low. Motion 3 L’s 15″ profile avoids sunroof/carwash strikes. XT L is too tall (17″).
Capacity Reality: Max 4–5 ski pairs (not 7) due to shorter roof. Prioritize low-profile packing.
Aero Need: Critical for sedan stability – Motion 3 L minimizes steering wander.

10. Tesla Cybertruck (2024+)

Wildcard Alert: Thule hasn’t certified fitment yet!
Prediction: Motion 3 L’s angular design will integrate better than XT L. Expect custom brackets.
Range Tip: Cybertruck’s efficiency nosedives with drag – wait for Thule’s CT-specific box.

Final Thoughts: Gear Up for Better Adventures

Choosing between the Thule Motion 3 L and Motion XT L isn’t just about picking a box; it’s about choosing how smooth your next adventure will be. The XT L is a proven workhorse, a reliable classic you can still find deals on. But the Motion 3 L? It represents the evolution – quieter, easier, smarter, and sleeker. It takes the friction out of using a roof box. For most adventurers investing new today, the Thule Motion 3 L is the way to go. The reduced noise, effortless operation, and clever features like SlideLock and PowerClick genuinely enhance every trip. It’s an investment that pays off in peace, quiet, and pure hassle-free adventure time. Ready to hit the road without the roof rack rage? The Motion 3 L has your back. Go load up and explore!

Article Team

Our team is creating outdoor-gear relevant articles with passion. If our articles can help you to find the correct solutions for your questions, we will be happy about that. In the content creation process, we usually collect accurate and useful information online or offline to compile our content in an organized way. Consequently, we can guarantee that you can discover some expected answers to your questions. We appreciate your time on our site.